By Associate Professor Dimitria Groutsis University of Sydney Business School
Dr Jane O’Leary Diversity Council Australia
Cathy Brown Diversity Council Australia
Australia boasts one of the most multicultural populations in the world. But after almost five decades of multiculturalism we still don’t have clarity around what cultural diversity is and therefore how to best measure and report on this cultural diversity.
While our census data provides us with a snapshot and a great benchmarking tool, it comes with limitations. It doesn’t give us a clear picture of who we are as Australians. Cultural diversity is more than just how a census data point defines you – it is also about the way someone else defines you, and how you identify, with all the complexity that entails.
If we are not capturing this more nuanced information, then we don’t actually know much about the landscape of our society and what our organisations look like.
To address this gap, DCA and the University of Sydney have worked together on a set of guidelines to help measure, monitor and report on cultural diversity.
What’s wrong with how we count culture at the moment?
Let’s take the example of a fourth-generation Australian woman with an Asian cultural background.
She grew up in Australia. Her parents grew up in Australia and she speaks English at home. She identifies as culturally diverse, and is identified that way by others (she is constantly asked “Where are you from?”) and yet, if her workplace conducted a diversity census using the traditional questions of "Where were you/your parents born?", it is unlikely the statistics would capture her as culturally diverse.
This one example highlights that we have a wonderful opportunity to develop a more nuanced understanding of what cultural diversity is within an Australian cultural context.
Why do we need to count culture?
Therefore, at a simplistic level, mapping the cultural diversity of an organisation’s workforce will enable organisations to assess how well their current workforce supports the markets, customers, and clients they seek to serve.
But it’s much more than that.
While we currently know very little about who our workforce is, we do know that there have been consistent structural barriers to career progression for workers from a non-Anglo-Celtic cultural background.
Without an accurate way to measure who is in our workforce, how can we capitalise on the capabilities and skills of our culturally diverse workforce? The sad reality is that the structures and systems have remained unchanged and unchecked and do not reflect the rich cultural diversity in Australia’s broader population. Decisions are being made, resources are being deployed in the highest layers of our institutions and yet, the voices of our culturally diverse population are silent in these decisions and in the distribution of resources.
How should we ‘Count Culture’?
Counting Culture in a meaningful and respectful way isn’t simple.
That’s why Diversity Council Australia and the University of Sydney Business School have developed 6 guiding principles to steer business, government and non-government agencies on how to measure and report on the cultural background of employees in a way that is respectful, accurate, and inclusive, and well suited to our contemporary multicultural Australian business context.
These guidelines build on over a decade of research into the experiences of culturally diverse people in Australian workplaces, and recognise the specific workplace experiences of Australia’s First Nations people.
Our guidelines articulate a more complex way of viewing cultural diversity that includes physical appearance, accent, dress, languages spoken, name and ethno-religious affiliation or, a combination of these factors - which taken together become markers of one’s cultural identity.
Aren’t we focussing too much on identity?
As the example above illustrates, a person’s country of birth and languages can only tell you so much about an individual. How they identify is just as important to understanding their unique perspectives and experiences of the world.
But similarly, asking an individual only about how they identify is limiting. For example, a recent migrant to Australia might identify strongly as Australian, but also speak another language and have cross-cultural skills that could be invaluable to an organisation.
That’s exactly why we advocate that to meaningfully and respectfully capture this information, there must be multiple indicators.
Meaningful measures of cultural diversity
Counting Culture presents a watershed moment for understanding our multicultural society and our multicultural labour market.
Our hope is that our campaign for counting culture will start a conversation about meaningful measures of cultural diversity. Our intention is to grow this agenda by establishing a platform for measuring, monitoring and reporting on cultural diversity to ensure that the policies implemented create material outcomes for workers and business, and therefore going beyond a ‘feeling’ of inclusion. In addition to providing a useful measure of the Australian landscape, they will also allow organisations to more effectively craft and implement diversity and inclusion policies to benefit workers.
More on counting culture